Skip to main content

Newcastle United have a young squad… but the numbers suggest we can’t use that as an excuse

Is Newcastle United’s youthful squad really to blame for their on-pitch struggles?
ByMatty Connelly
Fulham v Newcastle United - Premier League - Craven Cottage
Fulham v Newcastle United - Premier League - Craven Cottage | John Walton - PA Images/GettyImages

Newcastle United’s change of strategy this summer saw a number of more established names leave and younger talents arrive - that squad turnover alone has had something of a knock-on effect to the on-pitch performances at the start of this season.

But, while a lot of the inconsistency has been put directly down to the young, possibly naive nature of the Magpies set-up, there is some rather interesting data to suggest that the excuse of youth should be banished from our minds as we emerge from the current international break.

That is because, when looking at the statistics, the extent to which the Magpies have used their younger players doesn't appear quite as significant.

Newcastle’s young player stats

When looking at the number of minutes handed to players under-23 by all clubs in the Premier League, Newcastle United only sit 8th.

That means that, despite all of the conversations around how the Magpies don’t have much experience in their squad, seven teams above them have used more players in that under-23 bracket this season - including the likes of Brighton who are flying in the Premier League right now.

Similarly, when looking more closely at Newcastle’s squad, the new young signings are almost all on the lower end of the scale when it comes to their share of available minutes. Bamba and Toure are below 25% of minutes and Steur and Fernandez-Pardo both sit around the 30-40% mark.

Obviously there are certain nuances that those statistics don’t take into account, but for the most part they paint a slightly different picture from the one that places blame on the amount of youngsters in the squad.

What does it mean?

This isn’t to suggest that the number of young players at the club is playing no part, but instead that we maybe need to repackage the way we are thinking about the current cohort.

Perhaps it’s not that playing the young players is leading to naivety and inconsistency, because Jaissle actually isn’t using them anywhere near as much as it might seem.

It could instead be that, because the German doesn’t trust them, they aren’t actually having enough impact on the squad rather than having an inherently negative one.

Similarly, that raises a tension around whether Jaissle should actually be using them more than he currently is. The lack of impact they are having because of lack of that trust could well turn into a positive impact if he places even a little more faith in the players in question.

Thus far, the German has stuck by those who were at the club when Eddie Howe was in charge and failed to deliver the expected results last season. While it hasn’t gone horrifically wrong, the ongoing questions about performances do suggest a need for change in the near future.

If that is to come to fruition then, due to the make-up of the squad, Jaissle has no choice but to place a bit more confidence in players like Toure, Steur and Aladji Bamba.

And, while that may feel a little bit concerning, who is to say it won‘t be the making of Newcastle United this season?

Add us as a preferred source on Google