Newcastle Toons
Fansided

Newcastle United position breakdown: Goalkeepers

By Carson A Merk

EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - JULY 14: Newcastle goalkeeper Robbie Elliott warms up before the pre season friendly between Hearts and Newcastle on July 14, 2017 in Edinburgh, Scotland. (Photo by Christian Cooksey/Getty Images)
EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - JULY 14: Newcastle goalkeeper Robbie Elliott warms up before the pre season friendly between Hearts and Newcastle on July 14, 2017 in Edinburgh, Scotland. (Photo by Christian Cooksey/Getty Images) /
facebooktwitterreddit

In the first of a four part preview series, co-site experts Carson Merk and Roy Emanuel take a look at the Newcastle United shot stoppers.

After winning the Championship, Newcastle United return to the Premier League this weekend. Leading up to the opener against Tottenham, both of Newcastle Toons’ co-site experts analyze the Magpies’ current roster, position by position. We will start from the back with goalkeepers first.

On The Roster: Rob Elliot, Karl Darlow, Freddie Woodman, Tim Krul

Analysis

Carson Merk: While rumors are that Rafa has been searching high and low for a goalkeeper to bring in, personally I’m okay with Elliot as the first choice keeper. He brings Premier League experience and has looked strong in the preseason.

The backup spot gets a little more tricky. I don’t think you must sell him, but if the money is right, I wouldn’t be opposed to Darlow being sold. Adrian or Cedric Carrasso could come in and push Elliot. If they sell Darlow, but can’t bring in a new keeper, maybe Woodman shouldn’t go out on loan as he’s expected to. He wouldn’t get the benefit of regular playing time, but it would give him a chance to see Premier League action up close. Krul has been told he isn’t a part of the plans Tyneside, so he isn’t a factor.

Roy Emanuel: There certainly seemed to be a strong desire to bring in another goalkeeper ahead of the campaign, and I am a bit surprised that it did not happen. But Rob Elliot has done enough during his time at Newcastle to show why he should at least get the chance for a starting role this season. Krul is almost certain to be departing.

The main issue stems from Karl Darlow, as his handling throughout the summer was a bit odd. From starting friendlies to being left off the team sheet to playing less than 45 minutes, a change of scenery may be the correct remedy for all involved. I may be a bit optimistic, but I think Woodman can have a place in the side this year. Cup matches could be an excellent opportunity for Benitez to test his young keeper.

Projected Depth Chart

CM: Elliot, Darlow. Loan out Woodman, sell Krul.

RE: Elliot, Woodman. Sign another. Sell Krul and Darlow.